A not very clever attempt to mock belief:

'Rational Reasoning:
Jeff: I have a ball.
Jeremy: Prove it.
Jeff: *brings out ball*
Jeremy: Well proven.

Religious Reasoning:
Jeff: I have a ball.
Jeremy: Prove it.
Jeff: YOU CAN'T PROVE I DON'T HAVE ONE.'

THE LOGIC FAILS FOR A NUMBER OF REASONS:
1) Jeff's 2nd claim has still NOT been dismissed.
2) Jeff knows that he does have the ball in either scenario.
3) It is Jeremy's problem if he doesn't believe the truth.
4) In all probability, Jeff would have then explained how this might be resolved and has not been taken up on it.
5) The so-called 'rationalists' insist that we must accept evolution on their guesswork and extremely limited evidence.
6) You cannot 'experience' atheism.
7) You can experience God the Son!