Sunday, October 09, 2011

Hmm. What Could He Possibly Mean?

The Italian judge who presided over the Knox appeal, Judge Claudio Pratillo Hellmann, said 'the two were cleared of murder based on the evidence but that the real truth could be different.'

Do please remember that 'not guilty' and 'innocent' are two entirely different issues. In the UK we have seen many people have convictions quashed and then, 'the usual suspects' make disingenuous claims of 'innocence'. In such cases, I would guess that many fewer than 1% of these would qualify as innocent.
Courts already acquit countless people who are obviously guilty. I have done it myself. The system bends over backwards to ensure that 'all the ducks are lined up in a row' before a guilty verdict can be reached.
'Innocence' of a defendant in a court of law is an extreme rarity. It is almost impossible to believe that more than the tiniest handful could possibly be convicted.
After that comes the appeal when many more will have their verdicts overturned - and in some cases further appeals still.
From a mathematical point of view alone, 'innocents' in British prisons can probably be counted on the fingers of one hand - possibly with some digits to spare.
I once asked a court reporter how many innocents that he'd seen in courts. He pondered the question a short while and then responded with "None. But I've seen quite a few cases that should never have been brought."
The question was asked prior to my becoming a JP and I can honestly say that his words stayed with me for a decade and oh, how right he was!

The Brothers and Sisters of Jesus.

How much do we know about the brothers and sisters of Jesus? Neil Rees    19 October 2024. (Photo: Getty/iStock) Jesus had brothers and sist...