My Column – Make up your own mind about the EU referendum –
it is the most important decision we’ll make for a generation. Jonathan Arnott, UKIP MEP, North East.
The Labour Party is busy. In amongst the rifts and the factionalism, the Blairites versus the Corbynistas, the left versus the far-left, another fight is developing. This time, it’s about squashing dissent on the European Union. A small but growing band of Labour MPs have dared to put their careers on the line to speak out and stand up for an old Labour tradition of Euroscepticism; they say that Britain would be better off by leaving the European Union. In the days of Clement Atlee or Tony Benn – Hugh Gaitskell even – these dyed-in-the-wool Labour Party giants stood up against the forerunner of today’s European Union.
The Labour Party is busy. In amongst the rifts and the factionalism, the Blairites versus the Corbynistas, the left versus the far-left, another fight is developing. This time, it’s about squashing dissent on the European Union. A small but growing band of Labour MPs have dared to put their careers on the line to speak out and stand up for an old Labour tradition of Euroscepticism; they say that Britain would be better off by leaving the European Union. In the days of Clement Atlee or Tony Benn – Hugh Gaitskell even – these dyed-in-the-wool Labour Party giants stood up against the forerunner of today’s European Union.
Today that same charge is led by Kate Hoey, who I respect more than any
other Labour MP. There’s Frank Field, the solid Northern MP for Birkenhead.
Gisela Stuart MP was pro-European Union until she assisted in drafting the
European Constitution [now Lisbon Treaty], and what she saw put her off the EU
for good. Then there’s Khalid Mahmood, an MP from the Birmingham area who wants
to leave the EU to help his local business community. Kelvin Hopkins wants to
leave to boost workers’ rights, and to give the power to renationalise railways
and postal services. I might add Graham Stringer, Roger Godsiff or closer to
home, Ronnie Campbell – MP for Blyth Valley. Labour’s biggest private donor,
John Mills, is putting his money where his mouth is to join the campaign. At the
periphery, there’s a former Defence minister in Lewis
Moonie.
It’s a pretty solid base considering the vitriol aimed at them by their
own supporters. I’ve spoken to senior people in the various Leave campaigns;
their experience is that a large number of Labour councillors will privately
support EU withdrawal. But very few, if any, dare to go on the record. They’re
tearing their hair out with frustration at all the untapped support. I’ve heard
words along the lines of “I used to be a Labour councillor. I don’t agree with
UKIP on much, but we need to be out of the European Union” many times, often
through chance encounters when campaigning. Labour councillors have often turned
up to UKIP events, usually because they’re interested in leaving the
EU.
But don’t expect them to admit to it. Kate Hoey is branded a ‘serial
maverick’ by the deputy leader of Labour’s MEPs. I would have thought that David
Lammy MP’s comment that “A million Indians died fighting for us, they fought for
the European project” should be considered more maverick not least because he
rewrites history and forgets that the EU didn’t exist in any form until a long
time after World War 2.
Then one of the North East Labour MEPs attacks the Labour Leave website.
As I understand it, the Labour Leave – like Conservative Leave and so on – are
all umbrella organisations of Vote Leave. The Labour Leave website was set up by
some of the top people in Vote Leave. Cue faux outrage and an absurd leap of
logic, the Labour mavericks must be in cahoots with Tories! Spin aside, it’s no
more than pro-EU Labour MPs are in cahoots with David
Cameron.
Top Labour donor John Mills hits the nail on the head: ‘There are many
Labour MPs who do want out of Europe but won’t say so’. He’s right, even if he
does confuse the wonderful continent of Europe with the appalling European
Union. Indeed, even Jeremy Corbyn was for decades a staunch Eurosceptic. He
wouldn’t rule out campaigning to leave the EU until he realised that he might be
deposed by his own MPs if he did.
But for now the number of Labour MPs prepared to speak out against the
European Union remains small. It’s the tyranny of the majority; rebellion would
not be treated kindly. The Labour Party is broadly pro-EU, but it is not united.
It’s telling that when Mills called for Shadow Cabinet members to have the
freedom to campaign for a ‘Leave’ vote if they wish, no movement was
forthcoming. If such a policy applied to the Shadow Cabinet, then other MPs and
councillors might follow suit rather than lying low. Ultimately what certain
elements of the Labour Party don’t want you to know is that it’s okay to be
Labour and to want our freedom back from the European Union. I could say the
same incidentally about the Greens; Jenny Jones, former Deputy Mayor of London
and one of the Green Party’s three members of the House of Lords, is vocal in
the anti-EU campaign.
Why does any of this matter? Why am I, as a UKIP MEP, writing about the
Labour Party? Because the forthcoming referendum is the most important decision
we’ll make for a generation. I’d urge everyone to look at the issues for
themselves and make up their own minds, rather than unthinkingly vote according
to what they perceive as the Party line.
This article was originally published in The
Journal.