Agnosticism requires no such rigour.
Atheists must be challenged as to which position they adhere to.
Christians might respond with Psalm 34:8 - "Taste and see that the Lord is good."
The Christian position may be tested on an individual basis.
A 'step of faith' is required and God will honour that - if done honestly and with an open heart.
[Thanks to Randall Hardy for directing my thoughts in this direction.]